Submitted by: Donpl Alford
Cookie Jar Fakes and also Reproductions
The name McCoy and pottery and especially cookie jars belong collectively since this is a given, many dishonest dealers make an effort to exploit enthusiasts as well as collectors. This may be particularly common through Internet sales whenever buyers think they are businesses or purchasing an authentic vessel from the real McCoy Company. Numerous cookie jar fakes as well as cookie jar reproductions are usually prevalent.
There are reasons why a new collector would purchase a duplication or commemorative jar. A imitation jar should be both a great deal cheaper and easier to find compared to real thing. From my particular perspective, there is very little inappropriate by having a duplication jar associated with an aged container within your treasures, as long as you understand it is a reproduction jar when choosing it. And as long as the container is marked permanently and well enough that later on down the road there will be absolutely no question over it being a reproduction. Some jugs that fit into this group would include the Midwest Sailor man that is very similar to the Shawnee Sailor man jar, the Dept. 60 series of jars that are look-a-likes of some vintage jars. In addition there are authorized reproductions in more recent jars, such as the Henry Cavanagh series.
Reproducing licensed things is another story and one which is open to lawsuits. Stay away from illegal jars of licensed figures or trademarked jars. For starters, they are illegal and if you are enthusiastic about the monetary aspect, they’ll most likely never increase in benefit.
It’s when the reproduced containers are made to deceive would-be buyers that problems start.
The McCoy tag has been copied and abused on a multitude of jars (along with other pottery items). A McCoy mark has been used on reproductions regarding authentic McCoy jars. At one time it had been just the more valuable jars, these days even inexpensive McCoy jars are actually copied.
The mark has also been utilized on reproductions of jars from other companies. Brush, Treasure Create, Shawnee jars have all been duplicated with no shame on the part of these individuals.
McCoy is also placed on jars which can be obviously new designs or perhaps ceramic molds.
It has been said by some that these containers are the work of the “New McCoy Company”. This controversy has been going on since at least 1992 and in 2000 Joyce Roerig addressed this issue in her cookie jar book, Collector Encyclopedia of Cookie Jars.
A common ploy is the manner in which cookie jar fakes and also cookie jar reproductions are usually advertised for sale. For instance, as opposed to saying this is a McCoy jar, the owner might say, “McCoy is at the base of the jar”, not quite calling the item a McCoy jar, but certainly making you read between the lines. These jars have usually been found at house sales, thereby no historical past can be given. Or it may have been discovered in Grandma’s loft. Apparently Grandma was very busy in her attic generating all these jars. The majority of these kinds of jars have extremely large fake crazing on the jar, that is offered as proof of an indication of aging — it’s not! The crazing is normally darkish, completely covers the actual jar and is very also very even.
When looking at cookie jars on the web, and at shows, the Top 10 Reasons why bells should go off inside your head are:
1. The seller will not supply refunds.
2. The seller thought it was at the estate of a ninety-year old lady. Probably inside the attic of her house.
3. The vessel has a very distinct, hefty crazing covering the entire jar.
4. The seller has many auctions; all-featuring classic jars with the above explanations.
5. Size is not quite right — light and portable or shorter.
6. Youve not witnessed or heard of the container, but the seller has many for sale (check closed sales).
7. Many more bidders than is typical.
8. It is an exclusive auction or private feedback and comments.
9. More than three of four negative feedbacks.
10. As outlined by the description, it’s a vintage jar– photo is on eBay, in the background identical jars are located along side packing boxes (Sure, this really happened!).
Numerous Internet sites have very good sources about the growing problem associated with cookie jar fakes and also cookie jar reproductions. When you have any doubt about a jar, ensure you cover all the bases by checking out all available resources. If you still have a question about the credibility of a piece — it might be far better to pass on it and save the heartache of learning you’ve been the victim regarding fraud.
Dishonest dealers–some with as much eBay user names as days in the month–are offering phony, cookie jar fakes, along with cookie jar reproductions. Cookie jars on eBay without having disclosure that the jars are not authentic but copies. Unsuspecting buyers are purchasing these fakes, and more well-informed collectors and dealers are usually throwing up their hands with disgust and despair, fearing that the worth of prized cookie jars can plummet. Even serious hobbyists are becoming gun-shy about buying genuine jars.
About the Author: Long time antique and collectible
glasscottage.net/
specializing in glass, china, pottery and steamer trunks as well as providing information and research materials on hundreds of specific collectibles.
Source:
isnare.com
Permanent Link:
isnare.com/?aid=873775&ca=Arts+and+Crafts}
